"The First Time I Saw Him" Review: A Divisive Sequel

Quick Verdict

The First Time I Saw Him by Laura Dave is a divisive continuation of her thrilling mystery series, leaving readers polarized with its relentless pace and emotional depth. While some find it a gripping sequel, others are frustrated by its repetitive narrative style. If you enjoyed The Last Thing He Told Me, this may be worth your time, but be prepared for a mixed bag.

What It's About

Laura Dave's The First Time I Saw Him picks up five years after Owen's disappearance, with Hannah Hall and her stepdaughter Bailey settling into their new life in Southern California. The story kicks into high gear when Owen reappears at Hannah's art exhibition, thrusting the duo into a high-stakes quest to evade their past. The narrative explores themes of family, trust, and survival, all while maintaining the suspenseful tone that fans of the series have come to expect.

Writing & Style

Dave's writing style in this sequel is a point of contention. The book is marked by a rapid pace and a tendency for repetition, which can either heighten tension or become a source of frustration. For those who appreciate a fast-moving plot, the style might feel like a thrilling ride, but for others, it interrupts the narrative flow. The dual timelines and ensemble cast add complexity, reminiscent of works like Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn.

What Works

The book excels in maintaining suspense and delivering an adrenaline-fueled narrative. Fans of the first book will appreciate the seamless transition and the depth added to Hannah's character. The emotional stakes are high, making it a compelling read for those invested in the characters' journeys. The audiobook, narrated by Rebecca Lowman, adds another layer of engagement, especially for those who enjoyed her performance in the previous installment.

What Doesn't

However, the book is not without its flaws. The frequent use of flashbacks and repetitive elements can pull readers out of the story. Some may find the pacing overwhelming, while others might be disappointed by the lack of character development for Owen, whose reappearance should have been a pivotal moment. These aspects could detract from the overall experience for those expecting a more nuanced exploration.

Who Should Read It

The First Time I Saw Him is perfect for readers who thrive on high-stakes drama and emotional depth. If you relished the complex relationships and tension in books like The Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins, this sequel might resonate with you. However, if you prefer narratives with less repetition and more character depth, this might not be the ideal choice.

Final Score

7/10 - The First Time I Saw Him offers a thrilling continuation for fans of the series, but its repetitive style and pacing may not appeal to everyone. A solid read for those who crave suspense and emotional drama.