"It's Not Her" Review: A Gripping, Twisty Thriller

Quick Verdict

Mary Kubica's "It's Not Her" presents a thrilling narrative filled with suspense, but stumbles with an implausible ending. This thriller captivates with its character development and mystery, yet leaves some readers questioning its resolution.

What It's About

In "It's Not Her," Mary Kubica crafts a suspenseful tale that begins with a shocking discovery. Courtney Gray finds her brother and sister-in-law dead during a vacation at a lakeside cottage, while her niece Reese is missing. The small Wisconsin town, steeped in secrets, becomes a backdrop for a twisted search for truth. Kubica explores whether Reese is a victim or the mastermind behind the chaos.

Writing & Style

Kubica's writing is known for its ability to weave intricate plots and develop relatable characters. In "It's Not Her," she maintains her signature style with a fast-paced narrative and carefully interwoven flashbacks. The story unfolds through multiple perspectives, particularly Reese's, offering a deeper understanding of the events leading up to the crime. Kubica effectively builds tension, keeping readers engaged and eager to uncover the mystery.

What Works

The novel excels in character development and setting. The small-town atmosphere adds an eerie charm, and the characters feel authentic, reflecting modern family dynamics. The suspense is palpable, and the mystery is layered, with enough red herrings to keep readers guessing. Kubica's exploration of grief and its impact on decisions adds depth to the narrative.

What Doesn't

Despite its strengths, "It's Not Her" falters in its conclusion. The resolution, marked by unexpected twists, stretches plausibility, leaving some readers dissatisfied. The use of social media as a plot device feels unrealistic at times, detracting from the overall experience. Fans of the genre may find the ending lacks the shocking impact expected from a thriller of this caliber.

Who Should Read It

"It's Not Her" is perfect for readers who enjoy psychological thrillers with complex characters and a fast-paced plot. Fans of Mary Kubica's previous works will appreciate her consistent style and storytelling. However, those who prefer tightly wrapped conclusions may find the ending frustrating.

Final Score

7/10 - "It's Not Her" offers a captivating ride with strong character development and suspenseful storytelling, but its implausible ending may leave some readers wanting more.