It Could Have Been Her Review: Unearths Hidden Secrets

Quick Verdict

It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell is a suspenseful journey that reveals the dark underbelly of family secrets and personal trauma. While it captivates with its atmospheric tension and intricate character development, the pacing can be a hurdle for those expecting a rapid-fire thriller. This book is worth reading for fans of psychological depth and complex narratives, earning a solid 7/10.

What It's About

In It Could Have Been Her, Lisa Jewell weaves a tale of mystery and suspense set against a backdrop of long-buried secrets. The protagonist, Jane Trevally, stumbles upon a small terrier while walking her dogs on her estate. This chance encounter leads her to a rundown house in Hampstead, connected to her own traumatic past. As Jane delves deeper, she uncovers a web of deceit linked to a missing teenager, a creepy house, and a mysterious man named Stuart Tucker.

Writing & Style

Jewell's writing style is immersive, drawing readers into a world of suspense with vivid descriptions and well-crafted characters. Her ability to build tension gradually allows the story to simmer before reaching a boiling point. However, the novel's slow pacing might not cater to everyone, especially readers craving immediate action. Instead, Jewell opts for a methodical unraveling of the plot, reminiscent of classic mystery thrillers.

What Works

The novel shines in its character development and atmospheric setting. Jane Trevally is a relatable protagonist, pulling readers into her quest for truth. The eerie house, Thornwood, serves as a character in its own right, its presence looming large over the narrative. Jewell's exploration of themes like memory, trauma, and family ties adds depth to the storyline, making it more than just a typical suspense thriller.

What Doesn't

The primary drawback is the pacing. For readers accustomed to fast-paced thrillers, the first half of the book may seem sluggish. The introduction of numerous characters and subplots can initially overwhelm, potentially deterring some readers before the story fully hits its stride. Additionally, the book's conclusion leaves some questions unanswered, which could frustrate those seeking a neatly tied-up ending.

Who Should Read It

It Could Have Been Her is perfect for readers who enjoy psychological thrillers with a focus on character exploration and atmospheric settings. Fans of authors like Ruth Ware and Gillian Flynn will likely appreciate Jewell's nuanced storytelling. However, those who prefer fast-paced action and clear-cut resolutions might find this book less satisfying.

Final Score

7/10 - It Could Have Been Her is a compelling read for those who appreciate a slow-burn mystery rich in character and setting. While it may not suit everyone, it's a notable addition to the genre for its exploration of psychological depths and atmospheric tension.