Guess Again Review: Twists That Keep You Guessing

Quick Verdict

Charlie Donlea’s Guess Again offers a thrilling plunge into psychological suspense, where the past haunts and secrets kill. While the mystery's complexity captivates, its sporadic pacing could deter some readers.

What It's About

Guess Again by Charlie Donlea is a mystery thriller that delves into the chilling cold case of Callie Jones, a high school volleyball star who vanished a decade ago from her Wisconsin town. The narrative follows Ethan Hall, a former detective turned ER doctor, as he reopens the case at the behest of his dying former partner. The pursuit of truth leads Ethan into a dangerous labyrinth involving a notorious inmate and his own haunting past.

Writing & Style

Donlea employs a non-linear storytelling technique that oscillates between past and present, peppered with short, dynamic chapters. This structure injects a sense of urgency but may overwhelm readers who prefer a more straightforward narrative flow. The writing is sharp, immersive, and packed with tension, making it easy to get swept up in Ethan’s quest for closure.

What Works

Guess Again excels in maintaining suspense with its intricate plot and unexpected twists that challenge readers to continuously reassess their conclusions. Ethan Hall emerges as a compelling protagonist, his vulnerability and determination creating a character that resonates deeply. The interplay between Ethan and the enigmatic serial killer adds an exhilarating layer of psychological tension.

What Doesn't

Despite its gripping premise, the novel’s pacing can be jarring, with some readers finding the frequent shifts in time and location disorienting. While the twists are plentiful, the predictability of some detracts from the overall impact. Additionally, a few scenes feel superfluous, contributing to a lengthier read than necessary.

Who Should Read It

Fans of psychological thrillers like Riley Sager’s Home Before Dark or Karin Slaughter’s Pretty Girls will find Guess Again a worthy addition to their reading list. It’s perfect for those who relish complex mysteries with a psychological edge. However, if you prefer tightly woven plots without extraneous details, this may not be your ideal choice.

Final Score

7/10 - Guess Again by Charlie Donlea delivers an engrossing mystery with memorable characters, though its uneven pacing and some predictable twists slightly diminish its impact.