Do Not Disturb Review: Twists That Intrigue and Divide

Quick Verdict

"Do Not Disturb" by Freida McFadden is a thriller that captivates with its atmospheric tension and Hitchcockian influences, though it divides with its polarizing twists. While some readers will revel in its suspenseful homage to classics like "Psycho," others may find its narrative inconsistencies off-putting. Overall, for fans of psychological thrillers, this book offers an engaging, if somewhat uneven, ride.

What It's About

In this gripping fiction, Quinn Alexander finds herself on the run after committing a crime of desperation. Fleeing from a seemingly idyllic yet abusive marriage, she seeks refuge at the eerie Baxter Motel during a snowstorm. The motel, with its unsettling history and the ominous presence of the owner’s wife watching from afar, sets the stage for a tense encounter. As Quinn battles her past and the motel’s secrets, "Do Not Disturb" spirals into a web of mystery and survival.

Writing & Style

Freida McFadden's writing in "Do Not Disturb" is brisk and engaging, effectively capturing the claustrophobic feel of a thriller. Her narrative style, reminiscent of Shari Lapena, employs short, punchy chapters that keep readers on edge. However, the dialogue occasionally falters, with characters sometimes lacking distinct voices, which can dilute the story's impact.

What Works

The novel excels in creating a suspenseful atmosphere, drawing readers in with its nods to classic thrillers. The setting of the Baxter Motel is masterfully crafted to evoke a sense of dread and anticipation. McFadden’s ability to blend elements from "The Woman in the Window" with a modern take on "Psycho" adds a layer of nostalgia that thriller aficionados will appreciate. The plot’s initial setup is intriguing, with enough momentum to keep pages turning.

What Doesn't

The book's major flaw lies in its plot twists, which, while surprising, sometimes lack cohesion with earlier narrative elements. This inconsistency can disrupt the reading experience, leaving some readers feeling frustrated. Additionally, the character development can feel shallow, with motivations and actions that occasionally stretch believability.

Who Should Read It

"Do Not Disturb" is perfect for readers who enjoy fast-paced thrillers with a psychological edge, particularly those who have a penchant for stories set in creepy, isolated locations. Fans of Alfred Hitchcock’s work or readers who appreciated "The Woman in the Window" will likely find this book appealing. However, those who prefer tightly woven narratives with deep character exploration might find it less satisfying.

Final Score

7/10 — A thrilling homage to classic suspense, "Do Not Disturb" is a fun, albeit imperfect, read for fans of the genre. Its atmospheric setting and nods to cinematic classics provide a compelling backdrop, though the narrative inconsistencies may detract for some.