A Pair of Aces Review: Powerful Historical Drama

Quick Verdict

Marie Benedict's A Pair of Aces is a gripping historical fiction novel that dives deep into the 1930s criminal underworld of New York. With a focus on two formidable women, this book is a compelling read for fans of strong female leads and historical intrigue, though its pacing may test your patience initially. Is A Pair of Aces worth reading? Absolutely, especially if you value nuanced character development and a high-stakes legal drama.

What It's About

Set against the bustling backdrop of 1930s New York, A Pair of Aces follows the intertwining lives of Eunice Carter, the first Black female assistant district attorney, and Polly Adler, a high-society madam. Together, these unlikely allies aim to dismantle Lucky Luciano's criminal empire by targeting the mob's involvement in prostitution, a strategy previously unexplored by law enforcement.

Writing & Style

Benedict's writing is richly detailed, transporting readers to the gritty, vibrant streets of historic New York. The narrative unfolds with a slow-burning tension that builds to a thrilling climax. While some readers may find the initial pacing sluggish, the payoff is a meticulously crafted courtroom drama that highlights the societal challenges faced by women, particularly women of color, during this era.

What Works

The strength of A Pair of Aces lies in its complex characters and the unlikely partnership between Eunice and Polly. Their dynamic is electric, providing a fresh perspective on historical events. The meticulous research shines through, giving depth to the narrative and bringing to light the overlooked contributions of women in history. The book successfully combines elements of mystery, drama, and historical insight, ensuring a captivating read.

What Doesn't

Some readers might struggle with the book's pacing, particularly in the first quarter, where the investigative groundwork is laid. The slow start may deter those seeking immediate action. Additionally, certain character developments feel underexplored, leaving a few loose threads that could have added more depth to the protagonists' personal struggles.

Who Should Read It

This novel is perfect for fans of historical fiction who appreciate strong, multifaceted female characters and detailed historical settings. Readers interested in legal dramas and stories of social justice will find much to admire in Benedict's work. However, those looking for fast-paced action or less introspective narratives might find it less engaging.

Final Score

8/10 - A Pair of Aces is a well-crafted tale of resilience and justice that offers a fresh take on historical fiction through the lens of two pioneering women.